Skip to Main Content
Shop by CategoryCustom PuzzlesProgramsOn The Spot! EventsOur Store
  • Questions? Call us! 617-738-7352

  • Hours:

    Sun: 11am-7pm;

    Mon-Sat: 10am-8pm

  • 0 • $0
    • View cart
Shop by Category Halloween | EurekaPuzzles
  • Shop by Category Halloween | EurekaPuzzles
  • 0
  • Log in Create an Account
  • Shop by Category
    • Games
      • Board & Card Games
      • Chess
      • Other Traditional
      • Dice & TTRPG
      • Playing Cards
      • Trivia & Conversation Starters
      • Kids Games
    • Jigsaws
      • Adult Jigsaws
      • Wooden Jigsaws
      • 3D Jigsaws
      • Jigsaw Accessories
      • Kids Jigsaws
    • Mechanicals
      • Puzzles at Auction
      • Metal Mechanicals
      • Wooden Mechanicals
      • Puzzle Boxes & Locks
      • Rubik's Cubes and Twisties
      • Graduated & Logic Puzzles
      • Premium Mechanicals
    • Craft & Build
      • Book Nooks & Houses
      • More Wooden Kits
      • Metal Models
      • Paper Models
      • Fiber Arts
      • Kids Craft & Build
      • Tools & Accessories
    • Toys & Novelties
      • Kids Toys
      • Fidgets
    • Books
      • Crosswords
      • Sudoku & Other Logic Puzzles
      • Kids Books
    • Custom Products
      • Poster Printing
      • Custom Puzzles
  • Custom Puzzles
  • Programs
    • Summer Game Nights
    • Board Game Lending Library
    • After-School D&D
    • D&D Vacation Camp
    • Adult D&D One-Shots
  • On The Spot! Events
  • Our Store

Shop by Category

Games
Games
Jigsaw Puzzles
Jigsaws
Mechanical Puzzles
Mechanicals
Make It!
Craft & Build
Liquid error (snippets/image.load line 117): invalid url input
Toys & Novelties
Books
Books
Liquid error (snippets/image.load line 117): invalid url input
Custom Products
Skip to Main Content
Sort + Filter
Show
HomeShop by CategoryHalloween
Shop by Category
  • Games
  • Jigsaws
  • Mechanicals
  • Craft & Build
  • Toys & Novelties
+ More- Less
  • Books
  • Custom Products
Selected
  • Theme: Halloween
Type
  • Magazine Covers
  • Mini & Micro
  • Playing Cards
Piece Count
  • 100-299
  • 500
  • 750
  • 1000
Theme
  • Animals
  • Christmas
  • Disney
  • Food & Drink
  • Halloween
+ More- Less
  • Illustrations & Paintings
Age
  • 10+
  • Adult
Material
  • Plastic
Manufacturer
  • Eurographics
  • Galison
  • New York Puzzle Company
  • Pintoo
Bicycle Disney Nightmare Before Christmas Cards Bicycle Disney Nightmare Before Christmas Cards - 0

Bicycle Disney Nightmare Before Christmas Cards

Bicycle

$15.99

Halloween Candies 1000-Piece Puzzle Halloween Candies 1000-Piece Puzzle

Halloween Candies

Eurographics

$22.99

Spooky Shop (1000 pc)

Spooky Shop

New York Puzzle Company

$24.99

At Midnight (750 pc)

At Midnight

New York Puzzle Company

$23.99

Moonlit Mischief (500 pc)

Moonlit Mischief

New York Puzzle Company

$22.99

The 'Something Familiar Puzzle' by New York Puzzle Company features an illustrated scene with a whimsical witch observing animals in a shop window. The box displays the puzzle's name, total of 500 pieces, and dimensions of 18 x 24 inches. The artwork is colorful and playful, inviting nostalgia and imaginative storytelling. A whimsical 500-piece jigsaw puzzle titled 'Something Familiar' by New York Puzzle Company, featuring a witch with a broomstick observing playful cats in a pet shop window.

Something Familiar Puzzle (500pc)

New York Puzzle Company

$22.99

Menu

Footer menu
  • Search
  • About Us
  • Accessibility Statement
  • Report web accessibility issues
  • Careers
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Refund Policy
  • Shipping Policies
  • Terms of Service

Gift Cards

Looking to purchase a gift card? Please call the store and we'd be happy to take a phone order for shipping or pick up!

Call us at (617) 738-7352

Stay Connected

Sign up for our newsletter and stay up to date with the latest Eureka news! Information will not be shared or sold.

EurekaPuzzles © 2026

1355 Beacon St. Brookline, MA 02446 617-738-7352 info@eurekapuzzles.com

Powered by Shopify